![]() |
| Church of the Nativity by Niel Ward |
The alarm is being sounded throughout the Internet. “Kultureller Vandalismus” cries the German tabloid Suddeutsche Zeitung. The petition to save the Stratford campus is big news in South America: “Se lanza una petición para detener el cierre del Instituto Shakespeare en Stratford-upon-Avon.” [“A petition has been launched to stop the closure of the Shakespeare Institute in Stratford-upon-Avon.”] The petition had arrived at 2,900 firmantes at the time of publication.
Stratford-upon-Avon is the little town of Bethlehem of English literature. For the faithful, this move is the equivalent of removing the baby from the crèche. Or, more precisely, closing down the Church of the Nativity. The priests and the acolytes will have to be reassigned to other parishes at not-particularly-descript universities like Birmingham.
For hundreds of years the Shakespeare industry has exhibited the highest ideals of scholarship with the additional diktat: “If your finding does not fit the Stratford man, make it fit, or place your papers with the supermarket tabloids!” (Please forgive the anachronism.) At first, this ultimatum was wielded from innocence. But, for some 100 years now, that innocence has been steadily replaced by a cynical intention to keep the Shakespeare industry alive in its manifestations in Stratford and in academia. In many instances, it has been evangelized as a genuine matter of faith.
For well over a century, visitors have marveled at the courting settle "that Shakespeare sat on". (How he got Anne pregnant on the tiny bench, such that a hurried marriage was called for, truly boarders on the miraculous.) They now gaze upon examples from the figurines "carved from his mulberry tree" that miraculously multiplied on worshippers' curio shelves, for above a century, such that they collectively amount to a forest of secular mulberry trees. Perhaps most miraculous of all, visitors can leave with thick, pricey Shakespeare biographies suitable as their very own Shakespeare doorstop.
Only true believers can receive the story of “Stratford, with its little school,” [entry ticket and tour starting at $19.15,1] which taught Latin on a par with Oxford University2 while the only books most public school students possessed were a Latin catechism, an abecedarium and a notebook in which to take dictation of short passages from Latin classics recited by the teacher.3 Only when they properly reverence what until recently was described as the holy school-desk of the young Shakspere — from a time when there were no desks in backwater public schools, but rather benches along the wall, and none are mentioned in the ledgers of the Stratford town hall — can they understand the miracle. In the words of the church father Tertullian, about the story of the Christ: “prorsus credibile est, quia ineptum est... certum est, quia impossibile.” [It is entirely credible, because it is absurd... it is certain, because it is impossible.]
I would love to think that the authorities at the University of Birmingham made this decision with the conscious aim to separate itself from the myth and embrace the highest principles of scholarship. While Oxfordians need to accept the fact that the First Folio expressly forwards the Stratford man as the author of the works of Shakespeare and that he bought shares in the Globe Theater, Stratfordians need to accept the fact virtually nothing else in the historical record fits their man.
That the works of Shakespeare so closely hew to the biographical detail of the life of Edward de Vere, the 17th Earl of Oxford, and that, by textual evidence and revels records, the earliest works were written before William Shakspere of Stratford-upon-Avon had reached his teenage years or had ever been outside the immediate vicinity of his hometown, argues powerfully against William Shakspere as the author of the works.
William Shakspere was a representative example of the new up-and-coming English middle-class. This is what his limited biographical materials and Stratford's contemporary records and modern reconstructions teach us. He was a rough piece of work and constantly at work to increase his wealth and that of his family. Not many people from his strata of the society of the time managed to do as well. It is this that his story and Stratford's can properly tell us. It is something of which to be proud.
But, as fate would have it, he is more. He is a man who provided an available avatar for a nobleman who wrote the plays of Shakespeare — a spendthrift nobleman who lived by a dying code of honor that was coming to its end at the same time that the Stratford man was vigorously striving, as a British commoner, to have a greater share of the benefits of society — an effort that incidentally aided in lifting the rest of his class along with him. Their trajectories crossed. Each helped the other achieve their goals.
Birmingham has yet to explain its motives. It is probably too much to expect that the move amounts to a requirement that the Stratford myth must henceforward satisfy the scholarly standards that every other academic discipline is required to meet. The prospect vanishingly small that they might provide some bit of hope to Brexit-battered-Britain by reconsidering their decision, and, instead, open a second Shakespeare Institute campus at Hedingham.
Again, the anguished cries of Stratford would be heard around the world. The cries of “conspiracy theorists,” “on a par with holocaust deniers,” “elitists,” and “all the experts agree that alternative authorship is baseless,”4 will ring out in order to avoid an uncomfortable silence in the face of the facts of the case. In the face of the fact that we have spent some 360+ years — since the famous Shakespeare Jubilee of 1769 — ceaselessly contorting the historical record, and contorting the contortions when they came undone, in order to make the Stratford man the author of the works of Shakespeare.
Many years of media coverage, witty repartée and enhanced tourist traffic could lie ahead. A little something to occupy Britain's thoughts between stories of economic carnage. When a football game's not on the telly, that is.
Remember to “follow” this blog to receive notifications when new posts go up and to be able to comment on posts. The link is located in the upper right-hand corner of the page.
1 Shakespeare's Schoolroom & Guildhall Entry Ticket and Tour. The visitor is advised to book at least 19 days ahead. https://www.viator.com/tours/Stratford-upon-Avon/Shakespeares-Schoolroom-and-Guildhall/d22393-51286P1
2Purdy, Gilbert Wesley. “The Gospel of Shaksper According to Gilbert. Chapter 2.” Virtual Grub Street, October 9, 2022. Admission was listed as $13.54 when I first wrote this piece in 2022. https://gilbertwesleypurdy.blogspot.com/2022/10/the-gospel-of-shaksper-according-to.html
3Perhaps a tattered hand-me-down copy of Lily's Grammar, as well.
4See “supermarket tabloids” supra.
Also at Virtual Grub Street:
- On the Possibility that Edward de Vere and Shakspere of Straford Shared a Beer in Southwark. February 9, 2026. "The Earl of Oxford would have taken this route in 1575, as would Michel Eyquem, Seigneur de Montaigne,"
- Du Bartas – Dinosaurs = Shakespeare's Gaunt Speech in Richard the Second. November 30, 2025. "After quite some time it was discovered that one John Eliot's French lesson book Ortho-epia Gallica included..."
- Sonnet 130: Shakespeare's Reply to a 1580 Poem by Thomas Watson. September 7, 2024. “Interesting to see our Derek Hunter debating with Dennis McCarthy, at the North group,...”.
- Rocco Bonetti's Blackfriars Fencing School and Lord Hunsdon's Water Pipe. August 12, 2023. “... the tenement late in the tenure of John Lyllie gentleman & nowe in the tenure of the said Rocho Bonetti...”
Check out the Shakespeare Authorship Article Index for many more articles and reviews about this fascinating time and about the Shakespeare Authorship Question.
- Check out the V.G.S. Oxfordian Shakespeare Poetry Page for many poems by Shakespeare together with historical context.












